Building with nature and geology to protect against flooding
Discover how BGS is working alongside partners to investigate the effectiveness of natural flood management initiatives and mitigate the threat of flooding.
30/04/2021Beaver dams instead of concrete dams, re-meandering instead of dredging, floodplain parks and wetlands instead of concrete flood walls — who wouldn’t want to build with nature? For many years we have been doing just the opposite, fighting against the environment, attempting to conquer nature. The ecological impacts of these ‘hard engineering’ solutions are many, from trapping sediment and disrupting fish migrations to starving wetlands of water, turning them from greenhouse gas sinks into greenhouse gas sources.
Flooding and climate change
The aim of flood risk management is to protect people and property from the devastating impact of flooding. While a concrete wall may not add to the aesthetics or ecology of a river bank, it is usually a very effective means of achieving this aim. We need effective solutions because the risk of flooding is increasing in the UK, as the climate becomes wetter. In England and Wales, one study found that climate change has increased the risk of floods by at least 20 per cent and possibly by as much as 90 per cent. The latest Met Office climate projections show that winters will continue to become wetter in the UK throughout the 21st century.
Natural flood risk management
The UK’s river landscapes bear little resemblance to natural landscapes. We have created hard surfaces perfect for rapid runoff, built homes and roads on floodplains and straightened, dredged and built embankments on rivers, speeding up river flow, reducing infiltration and exacerbating downstream flooding. Natural flood risk management (NFM) aims to reduce flood risk by slowing the flow of water through the landscape. Native woodland, retention ponds and woody debris dams will all help to provide storage for water in the headwaters and, lower down in the catchment, floodplains will be restored. In doing so, NFM re-establishes the natural functions of river catchments, providing habitat for a diverse wildlife. It sounds perfect, doesn’t it? There is just one caveat — we are not sure how well it actually works.
There are now over 90 NFM projects in the UK, with around 15 active schemes. There have also been developments in policy to aid the implementation of NFM, such as SEPA’s production of an NFM handbook in 2016 and Defra’s 2017 review of the evidence base and production of guidance. Despite the increase in NFM implementation, monitoring and quantitative assessment of schemes remains low and evidence of effectiveness is still limited. However, investment in scientific research on NFM is on the rise and with it we expect find out what types of NFM work best and where.
BGS and flooding
Why is BGS interested in surface water flooding? What does NFM have to do with geology? BGS’s work on monitoring the effectiveness of NFM has focused on two areas: the Eddleston catchment of the River Tweed and the West Thames.
Eddleston
The Eddleston catchment is one of the most intensively monitored NFM observatories in the UK and BGS has been involved with the project since its inception. So far, we have found that:
- older and mixed woodland can absorb water a lot more quickly than plantation woodland
- narrow forest strips planted to prevent rapid hillslope runoff provide little subsurface storage during flood events
- understanding geology provides key insights into the hydrological behaviour of floodplains
Most recently, and perhaps most importantly, we have found that geology and soil type have a greater influence on rapid surface runoff than plantation forest cover.
West Thames
In the West Thames, BGS is working with the University of Reading and JBA Consulting, among other partners, to investigate the effectiveness of NFM in lowland permeable (chalk and limestone) catchments. We are studying measures such as crop choice, tillage practices and tree planting for their ability to increase evaporation and infiltration of water into chalk and limestone aquifers. The hope is that, by increasing infiltration, surface runoff and flood risk are reduced.
BGS’s role
But this water that infiltrates into the ground does not simply disappear. It is BGS’s job to understand what happens to this water once it has entered the bedrock: could groundwater levels rise, increasing the risk of groundwater flooding? Inversely, an increase in evaporation could lead to falling groundwater levels and water shortage in chalk aquifers, a major drinking water source in southeast England.
The move towards NFM seems like an obvious choice, given the co-benefits provided for wildlife and the problems associated with traditional flood measures. However, it is imperative that these schemes continue to be monitored and assessed for their effectiveness to make sure that their primary purpose — the protection of people and property from the economic and societal impact of flooding — is met.
And what does geology have to do with NFM? We need to ensure we are planting the right species of tree on the most suitable underlying geology.
About the author
Sarah Collins
Groundwater modeller
Relative topics
Latest blogs
Building stones spotlight: the Sir Walter Scott Memorial 25 years after its conservation
29/04/2024
BGS geologist, Luis Albornoz-Parra, discusses the iconic Edinburgh monument, the building stones used in its construction and the result (so far) of its conservation efforts.
Unlocking key mineral archives at the Zambian Geological Survey Department
23/02/2024
Rachel Talbot recounts a recent visit by BGS Records staff to the Zambian Geological Survey Department, to assist in critical mineral data management.
Will 2024 be the Year of the Aurora?
23/02/2024
The Sun’s approximate eleven-year activity cycle is predicted to peak this year, prompting BGS scientists to anticipate that 2024 will be the ‘Year of the Aurora’.
Hungry like a wolf: new insights from old bones housed in the BGS museum collections
18/01/2024
BGS scientists are studying the diets of ancient British wolves and how they adapted to changing environments.
How BGS is helping the farming sector of Great Britain
17/01/2024
New legislation concerning soil management and technology in modern farming has led to an increase in enquiries about BGS’s Soil Parent Material Model.
Moving stones: faults, slopes and sediments
12/01/2024
Fractured rock along faults affects sediment movement on slopes with implications for the design of infrastructure.
Understanding nutrients in tropical rainforests
11/01/2024
Christopher Bengt talks about carrying out research for his PhD amongst the rainforests and volcanoes of the Philippines.
Linking geochemistry and health in artisanal and small-scale gold mining in the Kakamega-Vihiga gold belt, Kenya
09/01/2024
PhD candidate Maureene Auma Ondayo is investigating major and trace element exposure in the environment in Kenya, aiming to reduce exposure of humans to toxic chemicals.
The Geography Olympiad: Bandung, Indonesia
22/12/2023
School student Dion Thompson joined Team UK at this year’s International Geology Olympiad in Indonesia. We hear from Dion’s mentor Anna Hicks, before Dion reports on the Olympiad itself.
CMIC: critical minerals research review
21/12/2023
Matthew Reeves of Innovate UK provides an overview of the Critical Minerals Strategy, which sets out how the UK will go about securing its supply of critical minerals.
My role as a stable isotope research assistant
19/12/2023
Charlotte Hipkiss has recently taken up a new position in the National Environmental Isotope Facility at BGS and gives us a little insight into her new position.
Groundwater in Taiwan under a changing environment
15/12/2023
BGS’s groundwater team is part of a project to develop the first groundwater forecasts for Taiwan.