Natural flood management: is geology more important than trees?
Looking at innovative ways of creating resilience to flooding hazards with natural flood management.
23/11/2023![Monitoring storm water runoff in the catchment using autosamplers to gather information on the isotopic and chemical composition of the river waters, and how this changes across the catchment depending on land use. © Leo Peskett / Heriot Watt](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/P1038306.webp)
![View of the Eddleston Natural Flood Management demonstration and research site in the Scottish Borders. This is one of a global network of UNESCO Ecohydrology Demonstration Sites. © Leo Peskett / Heriot Watt](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/P1038307-eddleston-natural-flood-management-demonstration-1.webp)
View of the Eddleston Natural Flood Management demonstration and research site in the Scottish Borders. This is one of a global network of UNESCO Ecohydrology Demonstration Sites. © Leo Peskett / Heriot Watt
Natural flood management (NFM) has become a key aspect of UK policy to reduce the risk of flooding, a hazard that is expected to increase under future climate-change scenarios.
What is natural flood management?
NFM seeks to control flooding by reducing or slowing the flow in river catchments using natural approaches. These include measures such as:
- planting trees to enhance infiltration and catchment roughness
- installing leaky wooden barriers within streams to create temporary surface water storage
- re-meandering rivers to reconnect them to their flood plains
Current understanding of natural flood management
There is growing pressure to change the way landscapes are managed at large spatial scales to respond to the climate and biodiversity crises. Despite its newfound popularity in UK policy, there are still uncertainties about the effectiveness of NFM at large spatial scales and for large floods. This is particularly true for measures that are dispersed across catchments, such as land-use change through afforestation or improvements to soil quality. Understanding how water is stored and released within catchments is vital for predicting the effects of these changes on both floods and droughts, as well as a host of other co-benefits such as biodiversity and agricultural productivity.
Recent work by Heriot-Watt University, the University of Edinburgh, BGS and the University of Dundee has started to look at these questions at the internationally important UNESCO ecohydrology demonstration site at the Eddleston Water natural flood management research site in the Scottish Borders.
Why is more research needed?
The infiltration of water into the subsurface is a key area of research in NFM including:
- how water infiltrates different soils
- the effect of different soil properties on infiltration rates
- the effect of different land uses on infiltration rates
In addition to understanding how easily water infiltrates, we also need to know how much water can infiltrate and where it goes — in other words, how much water can be stored? There has been much less research on quantifying catchment storage and the role of deeper catchment storage in the context of NFM, despite its potentially fundamental importance to our understanding of hydrology.
The effects of soils and geology on catchment storage
Using multiple methods, including water-level monitoring and stable isotopic tracers, our research estimated water storage across nine subcatchments and correlated the findings with catchment properties such as soil type, land cover and geology. We found that soils and geology dominated plantation forest cover in controlling catchment water storage, suggesting that the effects of changing forest cover are masked by more dominant soil and geological properties.
There are, of course, caveats to the work: we only looked at existing, mature conifer forests and only considered the effect of trees on storage. The impacts of trees on surface roughness and broadleaved trees, which are the main type planted by this and many other NFM projects, were not considered. While the differences are probably minimal, these questions need to be tested through further research. Our findings are, however, consistent with other work looking at land cover and catchment storage and catchment response to storms in Eddleston and elsewhere in Scotland.
Implications for natural flood management
These findings have two significant implications for NFM. The first is to add further criteria for determining the planting of the ‘right trees in the right place’. This storage perspective suggests that tree planting needs to be targeted at areas where potential storage is high but infiltration rates are low, such as highly compacted or degraded soils in relatively permeable catchments. The second is the need to understand dominant catchment controls on runoff in any NFM scheme, which means getting better knowledge of hydrological processes within catchments and their representation within models. We are exploring this second implication in a follow-up study combining stream flow data and water tracer data into a hydrological model, to see if this improves model outputs and therefore understanding of land use change in the catchment.
There is growing pressure to change the way landscapes are managed at large spatial scales to respond to the climate and biodiversity crises. Gaining a better understanding of catchment water storage across different environments is likely to be vital for predicting the multiple benefits and risks of nature-based solutions such as NFM. Future research using both empirical and modelling approaches needs to incorporate these perspectives to underpin effective future management strategies.
About the authors
![Alan MacDonald](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Alan_MacDonald.jpg)
Prof Alan MacDonald
Head of groundwater
Leo Peskett
Assistant professor in physical geography
Heriot-Watt University
Leo’s work focuses on evaluating the effectiveness of nature-based solutions in the land and water sectors and engaging with policymakers at international to local levels to bridge research and policy. His recent research has concentrated on:
- the integration of land and water management in the UK
- the impacts of land use on runoff in a natural flood management context
- the use of the natural capital approach in environmental management
Prior to academia, Leo spent a decade heavily involved in the development of global policies to reduce carbon emissions from deforestation (REDD+) and related climate change policies, working with the Overseas Development Institute, UN agencies and governments in the global North and South.
Relative topics
Related news
![Landslide aftermath. © Timo Volz, Unsplash](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/landslide-aftermath-timo-volz-unsplash.webp)
Studying multi-hazards from space
25/07/2024
A new European Space Agency-funded project will study the effect earthquakes have on occurrences of other natural hazards in the long-term.
![Scottish river in low flow. © Paul Glendell](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/scottish-river-in-low-flow.webp)
Warnings for Scottish farmers and distillers as new data indicates climate change may double number of droughts
23/07/2024
The agricultural and distilling sectors could face significant challenges after research finds the number of droughts in Scotland may double in the next 25 years.
![Coastal Erosion at Skipsea on the East Yorkshire Coast. © Matthew J Thomas / iStockphoto](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/iStock-1299945115_Holderness_Coast.jpg)
Spotlight on BGS coastal erosion data
18/07/2024
BGS GeoCoast data can support researchers and practitioners facing coastal erosion adaptation challenges along our coastline.
![The Lembang fault crosses the northern parts of Bandung city in Indonesia. BGS © UKRI.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/the-lembang-fault.webp)
Nearly three million people in Indonesia’s second city could be affected by an earthquake
17/07/2024
BGS-led research reveals the number of people in the Bandung metropolitan region who could be exposed to a major earthquake.
![North Sea Transition Authority](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/NSTA_image.jpg)
National Hydrocarbons Data Archive files now accessible through the National Data Repository
15/07/2024
Offshore well and survey information held within BGS’s archive have now been transferred to the North Sea Transition Authority’s National Data Repository to enable greater access.
![Pale cliffs above a flat grassy area with ivy and trees growing across some of them. There are several, large and small caves in the cliffs.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/geograph-6702517-by-Sandy-Gerrard.jpg)
Creswell Crags Museum collections offer insight into the past and future of wolves
12/07/2024
Bones found at the site are helping scientists to understand the diet of wolves and how they differ over time.
![Seabed geomorphology from part of the central area of the Offshore East Anglia seabed map. BGS © UKRI.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/seabed-geomorphology-offshore-East-Anglia-seabed-map-feature.webp)
New research reveals the secrets of the seabed off the East Anglian coast
11/07/2024
New geological map will help in the hunt for new renewable energy opportunities whilst protecting delicate marine ecosystems.
![GitHub logo](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/GitHub_logo.jpg)
Update released for BGS open-source database software, ETL Helper
09/07/2024
The software tool helps simplify the process of data transfer into and out of databases.
![Nine people in two groups (four to the left; five to the right) standing on grey rocks with brown cliffs behind them.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/tuscany-feature-image.jpg)
The heat beneath our feet: BGS field visit to Tuscan geothermal systems
05/07/2024
BGS visits the active and fossilised geothermal systems of southern Tuscany, Italy.
![Screenshot of the AGS4 file utilities tool and API with map markers over the UK.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/ags4-file-utilities-and-api.webp)
Update to BGS’s AGS file utilities tool released
19/06/2024
BGS has released significant updates to its online tool for validating geotechnical data held as AGS files. The update includes improvements to the tool’s user interface and the ability to convert AGS data into MS Excel files.
![Murrayfield Stadium located in Edinburgh, Scotland - © Thomas Feige / iStock.com](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Murrayfield_Stadium.jpg)
Quake it off: Taylor Swift concerts shake Edinburgh
13/06/2024
Seismometers around Edinburgh were triggered by the rapturous Murrayfield crowds over the weekend.
![Visitors taking part in the demonstration in BGS’s conference suit. BGS © UKRI.](https://www.bgs.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/P1051253-sized.webp)
BGS opens its doors to visitors at its Open Day in Keyworth
12/06/2024
BGS hosted its bi-annual Open Day on 8 June 2024, welcoming more than 1000 visitors to its headquarters in Keyworth, Nottinghamshire.